Skip to main content

Canada’s involvement in the war in Afghanistan - Was it worth it?

 


Words almost fail me. Yes, you read that right. Words do not come easy to me on the topic of Canada and Afghanistan. Amidst the still fresh news about next month’s election, the fledgling 4th wave of the pandemic, the anxiety associated with the safety of students starting school soon, the incessant news about destructive wildfires throughout Canada, the resounding continuation of despair and loss associated with colonialism and racism, and the opiod crisis amongst other topics of despondency, I hang my head and try to comprehend our involvement in Afghanistan.
According to The Canadian Encyclopedia (TCE), Canada sent over 40,000 Canadian Armed Forces members to Afghanistan during our 12-year war with the Taliban. TCE records that the war killed 165 Canadians — 158 soldiers and 7 civilians and over 2000 received physical wounds. Scores and scores of Canadian veterans, TCE recounts, came back home from the horror of war in Afghanistan suffering from post-traumatic stress injuries. Our soldiers, our neighbours, friends, and family members were involved in the war in Afghanistan from 2001 to 2014 and the Taliban recently took back the country in a few meagre months.
My head droops further.
Emotions run rampant inside me. I knew folks that served there. I have read of how those who returned are continuing to suffer from post-traumatic stress injuries and how oh so many have subsequently taken their own lives.
Retired Maj.-Gen. David Fraser said in a recent Global News interview that “he still remembers each life lost while he was leading the forces — 35 Canadians, 79 members of the broader coalition fighting contingent. When asked what he would say now to the families of those who died serving, as well as to those who sacrificed their lives in the war, he did not hesitate.”  “You did what you were asked to do. Politicians sent you, but you gave it your heart and your soul to try to provide hope and opportunity to people who didn’t have it — that we take for granted,” he said. In the same interview Fraser said “I think each and every one of us will ask ourselves the question for years to come: was it worth it?”
Amidst the sickening details of so-called ‘news’, I challenge someone, anyone, to make sense of it all. If there is anything that can be done, in the next wee while, it is to challenge the political machinations of the heretofore ruling parties that have plagued Canada since Confederation and before hand. We must look inward and outward and realise that the status quo of political ‘to-ing and fro-ing’ has not worked. We must seek out a new political framework that will strive to meaningfully address climate change, the wretched aftermath of colonialism and racism and one that does not support violence of any kind.
It is the meaningless violence that makes my head hang in despair and shame. Violence against our Earth, against our environment, our air, our water, our land – indeed against us, our children and grandchildren – against people.
With the passage of time, my head will straighten up. I will not remain stooped. For Canadians, of all creeds, colours, and origins, despair regarding the so-called ‘news’ over the past couple of weeks, must be replaced with hope and the pursuit of peace and reconciliation. These things must be seen and calmly held high as our collective mantle. Indeed, these efforts, for the benefit of generations to come, will surely be worth it.

Originally published in the North Renfrew Times – 18 August 2021

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Community Civics - where have they gone?

Recently, I was at a solemn public function that involved the playing of our national anthem, a formal ‘moment of silence’ and some meditative/prayerful time. The venue was packed shoulder to shoulder and many folks knew most of those in attendance, but there were obviously some from out of town. The lack of community civility during the ceremony was disrespectful and in my opinion rude. While the displays were not malicious in nature they certainly showed a lack of situational awareness and communal civic minded manners. Where ever has our community civility gone to? At the function I mentioned above, many adults ignored the playing of the national anthem and kept right on saying hello to those they had not seen in a while and continued to put cream and sugar into their tea and coffee. Few were singing our national song and most were not turned to face the prominently displayed Canadian flag. Sheesh – would it hurt you to at least turn and face one of our most visible national symbo...

It’s time to take action against PTSD

It’s time to take action against PTSD December 08, 2014 Written by Douglas Tennant Originally published in Firefighting in Canada Clara Hughes, Canadian Olympic cyclist and speed skater, came to my town during the summer and huge crowds came out to welcome her and listen to her speak. Hughes’ visit was a planned stop on Clara’s Big Ride, an annual bike ride across the country to encourage healthy conversations about mental illness – including post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).  PTSD? Isn’t that a severe mental illness for which only soldiers, police officers and paramedics are at risk? Me – suffer from traumatic events? I don’t think so. After all, I’m a firefighter. Yes, I still ride in the officer seat and wear a SCBA at calls, but I am tough. Firefighters don’t suffer from mental illness and we certainly aren’t affected by what we see, smell, hear, feel and otherwise sense at emergency scenes.  PTSD is defined by the Ontario government as an anxiety disord...

Mind the leadership gap

Mind the leadership gap September 22, 2015 Written by Doug Tennant Originally published in Firefighting in Canada There is a struggle these days at the top level of fire-service management. The struggle is internal; chiefs must decide whether to concentrate on public safety or support the political/fiscal war on spending.  I hear rumblings that the cost of emergency services is increasing too fast. We need to cut costs; taxpayers can not afford to continue to pay high prices for fire protection. I also hear the concerns from the public when a toddler dies in a house fire. Such was the case in January 2014 when a two-year-old died in a house fire in Langley, B.C., Shortly after a fire in May of 2015, Fire Chief Rick Ennis, chair of the Missouri Fire Sprinkler Coalition, asked on social media, “Why are we not giving the [recent] fire death of a two year old in a new home the attention it deserves?” I personally and professionally know the pressures and stresses of...